Skip navigation

By David McClard

recent article in the New York Times financial section described a horror story involving an insurer whose protracted financial meltdown caused the loss of $4.5 billion to its policyholders, including over a million dollars for a little girl with a hospital visit-caused brain injury.  The author made the assurance that such financial fiascos are rare with insurers because of the strict guidance and watchfulness of state insurance regulators. (But this assurance contains no consideration of the limited ability of insureds to collect more than remedial sums in ERISA-governed plans, thanks to O’Connor’s dicta in Pilot Life v. Dedeaux.)

The economic situation is now roundly considered precarious in almost every sector, and life and health  insurance companies do not seem to be the exception. For anyone who is convinced that their insurer is on the brink of a collapse, they are forced into the unenviable position of having to chose whether or not to pull out of a policy prematurely. It’s usually not something an insured ever wants to do (because of tax issues, penalties, paperwork, et al), but if it has to be done, there are some tips on making the next step a safer one:

1)When choosing a new insurer, consult with more than one agency rating. Each have their own criteria for rating insurance companies, so results may vary. The major raters A.M. Best, Fitch Ratings, Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s. 2) When shopping among the top-rated companies, be wary of terms which seem too good to be true, and exotic riders to policies. 3) Be extremely careful of gaps in coverage when switching policies. 4) Spread coverage over two (or three!) policies to hedge against an insurer financially tanking.

This advice is understandably disheartening, since it implies that the life and health insurance industry is now more than ever full of dangerous pitfalls.



  1. Now sometimes insurance carriers, whose business is health, do close or go insolvent. Many of these carriers did not have an AM BEST rating, ( since they did not buy a rating from AM Best to sell their commercial debt to the public, so you couldn’t judge the financial health of the carrier, or would have a rating not indicative of it’s ability to operate.,(formerly Weiss Ratings) rates insurance companies based on public information filed in States and, in our opinion, is an excellent tool to compare carriers. Don’t look for an A+ rating from any of the health carriers. A grade of C+ or better is, in our opinion, safe to do business with.

  2. I have been wondering about the extent to which the current economic situation may affect life and health insurance. I know that many of the companies that have fallen from grace also have health insurance divisions (AIG springs to mind). As far as I’ve heard though, most of these companies say something to the effect of, “Our ‘sub-prime’ divisions got hit real hard but we’re o.k. everywhere else”. I don’t really know one way or anything as to the validity of such statements but this post is not so surprising I think.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: